Beyond the Org Chart (Part I): Critical Questions for Leaders During Onboarding
Industry Trends
The early days of an executive’s tenure are filled with promise and pressure—it’s a time of introductions, immersion, and inevitable information overload. While most onboarding processes focus on organizational charts, strategic priorities, and compliance, the most successful leaders know that the real work lies beyond what's written down. They understand that every organization—no matter how structured on paper—has its own ecosystem of relationships, histories, and unspoken truths. This article outlines two critical questions new leaders must ask to decode the visible and invisible dynamics that shape organizations—and to lead with clarity, integrity, and inclusion.
Organizations we partner with
Bata Shoe Museum, Canadian Council for the Arts, CEE Centre for Young Black Professionals, City of Toronto, David Suzuki Foundation, Fasken, Genome Canada, George Brown College, GTAA, Humber, IMCO, Kids Help Phone, Luminato, McMaster University, MLSE, OICR, Ontario Presents, ROM, Sankofa Square, Sick Kids, TD Bank, TTC, UHN Foundation, United Way Greater Toronto, University of Toronto, University of Waterloo, University Pension Plan Ontario, York University
Clients Served Include
When new leaders step into an organization, much of their attention is understandably drawn to what’s visible: structure, metrics, role descriptions, and strategic plans. But beneath that surface lies a deeper, more influential layer—one that includes informal power structures, cultural expectations, and shared (but unspoken) histories. Too often, onboarding processes neglect this terrain, leaving new leaders to navigate the invisible by trial and error. Yet what is not immediately visible is often what shapes how decisions get made, which ideas gain traction, and why change efforts succeed or stall.
In this first instalment of a two-part series, we explore the questions leaders must ask—not to fill a checklist, but to build clarity and credibility. We begin with two foundational inquiries: Who really holds influence here—and how is it exercised? and What are people afraid to say out loud? Together, they form the groundwork for understanding not only how an organization functions, but how it feels.
These are not one-time questions—they are postures. And leaders who adopt them from the start are far more likely to create the kind of relationships and insight that drive sustainable, human-centred leadership.
1 Who really holds influence here—and how is it exercised?
On paper, the lines of authority are clear. But formal authority is only one piece of the puzzle. Informal power—the ability to influence decisions, shape culture, or serve as a trusted voice—often resides elsewhere.
Michael Watkins, in The First 90 Days, underscores the importance of mapping not only the organizational structure but also its power dynamics. Without understanding where influence truly lives, leaders may misread stakeholder expectations or inadvertently bypass key voices, weakening their credibility early on (Watkins, 2013, pp. 10-15).
Understanding influence involves identifying culture carriers, trusted advisors, and informal brokers who quietly shape consensus. These individuals may not hold senior titles, but their roles in guiding sentiment and operational decisions are pivotal. To uncover these players, leaders must approach their first days with structured curiosity:
Conduct stakeholder mapping: During early one-on-ones, ask, “Whose perspective should I hear before making decisions?” Watch for names that surface repeatedly across departments.
Use influence mapping tools: Consider tools like OrgMapper or simply draw informal relationship maps to visualize who talks to whom—and who holds sway.
Observe meeting dynamics: Who do people look to for nonverbal cues? Who interrupts without pushback? Who influences the outcome, even without speaking much?
Ask trusted staff: Executive assistants, project coordinators, and long-tenured team members often know where power really lies. A well-placed, “Who helps things really move around here?” can unlock a world of insight.
Another practical move: schedule informal “discovery coffees” across levels and departments—not just with your direct reports. Position these as learning conversations, not performance assessments. These chats often reveal not only who has influence, but how that influence is earned, how it’s perceived, and how it can help (or hinder) your early efforts. Influence is visible—if you’re watching for it. But more than that, it’s discoverable when you ask sincerely, listen generously, and look beyond the chart on the wall.
2 What are people afraid to say out loud?
Every organization has its ‘undiscussables’—topics or truths that stir discomfort, evoke defensiveness, or have been historically dismissed. These unspoken realities often exist in the spaces between formal policies and lived experience. And while silence may offer short-term stability, it erodes long-term trust. These are the places where resistance festers, risk hides, and innovation stalls.
In her book The Fearless Organization, Amy Edmondson reminds us that psychological safety isn’t about comfort—it’s about candour. High-performing teams are those where members feel safe to speak up, offer dissenting views, and challenge assumptions without fear of retribution (Edmondson, 2018, p. 5). Yet candour rarely emerges on its own. It must be invited—and it must be protected.
Leaders set the tone. If team members sense defensiveness or detachment, they will stay silent. But when leaders model vulnerability and openness, they create a culture where speaking the truth becomes not just safe but expected. New leaders can begin building this trust with intentionality:
Ask permission to learn aloud: Phrases like, ‘I know I’m still learning—what am I not seeing?’ or ‘What would a courageous conversation sound like here?’ invite honesty while signalling humility.
Host skip-level conversations: Speaking directly with people a few levels removed from your own role often reveals operational friction points, cultural inconsistencies, and hidden frustrations that aren’t visible from the top.
Use structured listening tools: Try anonymous Q&A platforms (e.g., Slido, ThoughtExchange) in town halls or team meetings to surface issues that people might hesitate to voice out loud.
Create ‘red flag rituals’: Some leaders make it routine to ask in team huddles: ‘What’s one thing we’re avoiding that we shouldn’t?’ Over time, this repetition normalizes the naming of uncomfortable truths.
Make it safe to challenge you: Offer explicit permission by saying, ‘If I miss something important or move too fast, I want you to call me on it. That’s how we’ll do our best work.’
Most importantly, don’t punish honesty—even subtly. If someone takes a risk to name a tension or disagree, respond with curiosity, not correction. Thank them. Dig deeper. Revisit the issue later, even if the answer isn’t immediate. Listening with openness—and without rushing to fix or defend—is not just an act of empathy. It is a strategic move that allows critical truths to surface before they become crises. The leaders who hear what others fear to say are the ones who earn long-term trust—and create workplaces where everyone can thrive.
Conclusions
Leadership starts with listening—and the questions you ask shape the answers you’ll receive. In Part I, we explored the importance of discovering where influence truly lives and creating the safety for truth to surface. These actions aren’t just helpful—they’re foundational. By observing power dynamics and cultivating psychological safety, new leaders lay the groundwork for trust, connection, and credible decision-making. They begin to show—not just say—that they are here to learn, not just to lead.
In Part II, we’ll continue this journey by exploring what success really looks like, how to navigate inherited legacies, and how to expand the circle of inclusion in meaningful, measurable ways. Until then, let the questions guide you. Because leadership that listens first is leadership that lasts.
Bibliography
Edmondson, A. C. (2018). The Fearless Organization: Creating Psychological Safety in the Workplace for Learning, Innovation, and Growth. New York: Wiley.
Watkins, M. D. (2013). The First 90 Days, Updated and Expanded: Proven Strategies for Getting Up to Speed Faster and Smarter. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Business Review Press.
President and Managing Partner
Add a comment
This will be publicly visible.
Your email address will not be published.
Your comment will be reviewed by an admin before it is published.
Professional Development / Melissa Sumnauth
The Hidden Conditions Leaders Overlook: Unlocking Creativity
In this article, Melissa Sumnauth invites us to rethink how workplaces approach growth and learning, challenging the contradiction between a desire for innovation and cultures marked by stress, fear, or emotional rigidity. With over a decade of leadership development experience, and certifications in Adult Learning & Development and Transformative Mediation, Melissa merges her professional expertise with her lived experience as an Indo-Guyanese-Canadian settler woman to offer an intersectional perspective on what it truly takes for people and organizations to thrive. She argues that learning and creativity cannot simply be demanded; they are cultivated through psychological safety, trust, and inclusive design that values every voice.
Industry Trends / Jason Murray
Reading the Room: How Chairs Steer Committees Toward Stronger Hires
In this article, Jason Murray explores the nuanced dynamics that can shape hiring outcomes when search committees are involved. He outlines practical strategies for Hiring Managers and Committee Chairs to cultivate structure, promote balanced participation, and avoid common pitfalls. Drawing from years of experience in executive search, Jason offers tools to help leaders ‘read the room’ and ensure that decision-making processes lead to thoughtful, equitable, and successful hires.
Sustainability / Erica Ing
Greenwashing vs. Authentic Sustainability: An Evaluation
Sustainability has evolved from a peripheral concern to a central pillar of modern business strategy, offering benefits that extend far beyond environmental impact. Companies genuinely committed to sustainable practices attract top talent, foster deeper employee engagement, and build long-lasting brand loyalty. However, the rise of greenwashing—making superficial or misleading environmental claims—threatens to undermine these gains, eroding trust and credibility. Authentic sustainability demands integration into core business values, active employee participation, and measurable, transparent progress. By prioritizing real action over appearances, leaders can harness sustainability as a strategic advantage, driving innovation, cost savings, and resilience while aligning with the values of a more environmentally conscious generation.
Professional Development / Urmilla Mahabirsingh
Elevating Talent Management and Recruitment with Yoga: Cultivating Mindfulness and Wellness
In the demanding world of talent acquisition and management, professionals often face high stress and complex challenges. Yoga offers a powerful tool to cultivate balance, resilience, and mindfulness, enhancing both personal well-being and professional effectiveness. By integrating practices like deep breathing, meditation, and targeted poses such as Mountain Pose or Warrior Pose, professionals can reduce stress, boost creativity, and improve communication. This article explores how yoga can empower talent managers to navigate their roles with composure and innovation, fostering a healthier work-life balance and driving organizational success.
Sustainability/Stephanie La
Green AI: The Role of AI in Sustainability
Green AI emphasizes the importance of balancing innovation with environmental responsibility, addressing the significant environmental and ethical challenges posed by AI development, such as high carbon emissions, energy consumption, and data privacy concerns. While AI offers transformative benefits, including climate change prediction, pollution monitoring, and public health insights, its rapid advancement often prioritizes speed over sustainability. By adopting Green AI practices—such as energy-efficient algorithms, renewable energy sources, and sustainable development goals—organizations can reduce their environmental impact, align with sustainability objectives, and foster long-term growth while contributing to a more sustainable and equitable future.
Leadership/Melissa Sumnauth
The Importance of Pronouncing a Name: An Act of Inclusive Leadership
Names are not just labels; they are powerful reflections of identity, culture, and history. In this article, Melissa Sumnauth explores the significance of correct name pronunciation in leadership and organizational culture. Drawing on her experience in executive coaching, executive search, facilitation, and people & culture she illustrates how mispronunciation can function as a microaggression and a barrier to inclusion, while intentional effort to say names correctly fosters dignity, belonging, and trust. With practical tools and a call to action for leaders, this article reframes name pronunciation as a vital practice in advancing equity and respectful engagement.